Wednesday, February 11, 2015

「習主席9月訪米」を報じるのに、米国から同時に招待された安倍首相の訪米計画については何も触れないメディアのおかしさ

まだの人はまずこちらの投稿を読んでください。

オバマ大統領が、安倍首相と習主席を国賓待遇で招待したことを同時発表―日本メディアの鈍い反応
http://peacephilosophy.blogspot.ca/2015/02/blog-post_10.html


2月11-12日、以下のようにメディア各社が中国主席習近平氏の9月訪米決定を報じている。

[日経]中国主席、9月訪米 オバマ大統領と会談へ http://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXLASGM11H2V_R10C15A2FF2000/
「習氏就任後の訪米は2013年6月以来、2回目。オバマ氏と会談するほか、国連創設70周年の記念行事にも出席する。」

[産経]中国主席、9月訪米へ オバマ大統領と電話会談
http://www.sankei.com/world/news/150211/wor1502110028-n1.html

http://www.news24.jp/articles/2015/02/11/10269064.html

[TBS]中国・習近平国家主席が9月訪米へ
http://news.tbs.co.jp/newseye/tbs_newseye2417119.html
「中国外務省によりますと、両首脳は電話会談で「反ファシズム戦争勝利70周年」について意見交換をしたほか」

[NHK]中国主席、9月訪米 オバマ大統領と会談へ
http://www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20150211/k10015381821000.html

[読売]習主席、9月訪米…「戦勝国」国際社会に誇示か
http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/world/20150211-OYT1T50077.html
「習氏の9月訪米には、主要な「戦勝国」としての立場を国際社会に誇示する狙いがあるとみられる。」

[朝日]
習近平主席、9月に訪米へ 戦勝70年、安倍政権牽制か
http://www.asahi.com/articles/ASH2C5DYQH2CUHBI016.html
 「習氏は国連発足70周年の記念行事にも出席。今年を「反ファシズム戦争勝利」70周年と位置づける中国の立場を強調し、安全保障の見直しなどを進める日本の動きを念頭に「戦後国際秩序の維持」を訴える見通しだ。」
「習主席は安倍首相による「戦後70年談話」の内容などを見極めた上で、9月をピークに歴史問題を巡る外交的な駆け引きを強めるとみられる。」

[毎日]
中国:習近平国家主席が9月に米国を公式訪問
http://mainichi.jp/select/news/20150212k0000m030030000c.html
「中国国営新華社通信によると、オバマ氏は今年9月の国際連合創設70周年の記念活動に合わせて米国を国賓訪問するよう習主席を招き、習主席は受け入れたと伝えた。」
確認できた限りでは、2月6日に米国が習近平氏招待と同時に安倍首相も招待していることに触れている記事が一つもない。これにはびっくりだ。

「その件は忘れてちょうだい」と言わんばかりである。

国連創設70周年行事がいつかは不明だが、毎年国連総会が9月下旬ごろあることからその時期ではないかと思われる。中国では「9.18」として記憶される満州事変の日に大きな記念行事があると思うので習主席はその直後に訪米するのではないかと予想される。

朝日新聞は「今年を『反ファシズム戦争勝利』70周年と位置づける中国の立場を強調し」などと言っているが、そう思っているのは中国だけではなく、逆にそう思っていないのは日本だけ――日本がこの戦争でいかに世界に迷惑をかけたかを知らない、知りたくない日本人だけであるという現実を踏まえて報道した方がいい。

朝日はまた、「習主席は安倍首相による『戦後70年談話』の内容などを見極めた上で、9月をピークに歴史問題を巡る外交的な駆け引きを強めるとみられる。」と言っている。何でも中国のせいにしてはいけない。安倍首相が「安倍談話」で侵略戦争に対する謝罪をトーンダウンするのではないかと心配しているのは中国だけではなく米国をはじめ、全世界である。

安倍首相が8月15日に出す「安倍談話」がもし、侵略と加害への反省を薄めるような内容であったら、ファシズム日本を倒した連合国が中心となっている国際連合を代表して、習近平首相とオバマ大統領がタグを組んで徹底的に国際社会ににおける日本への批判を強めるということである。

そこまでしっかり書けない日本のメディアは日本の読者を欺いているとしか言えない。

安倍政権は逆にバカではないだろう。それぐらいのことはわかっているはずだ。

だから安倍政権は今うろたえていて、米国からの国賓待遇の招待を、なんとか自分たちにあまり不利にならないように調整できないかと苦心しているのではないだろうか。

@PeacePhilosophy

Monday, February 09, 2015

オバマ大統領が、安倍首相と習主席を国賓待遇で招待したことを同時発表―日本メディアの鈍い反応

この投稿は2月11日に加筆修正して再投稿しております。


ブルッキングズ研究所HPより
オバマ大統領が習近平国家主席と安倍首相を国賓として招待すると、スーザン・ライス大統領補佐官(安全保障担当)が2月6日、ブルッキングズ研究所における講演で発表した。この講演はオバマ大統領が5年ぶりに発表した「国家安全保障戦略」の概要を話すものであった。ホワイトハウスのウェブサイトにその講演の全文が掲載されており、その中に招待のことも書いてある。
Remarks by National Security Advisor Susan Rice on the 2015 National Security Strategy
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/02/06/remarks-national-security-advisor-susan-rice-2015-national-security-stra

・・・With China, we’re building a constructive relationship that expands practical cooperation across a wide spectrum of issues from global health to non-proliferation, even as we confront real differences over human rights, cyber-enabled economic espionage, and the use of coercion to advance territorial claims.  President Obama’s recent trip to India strengthened another critical partnership that will deliver economic and security benefits for both our nations and the broader region, and help lift up the lives of more than a billion people.  In furtherance of our relationships throughout the region, I’m pleased to announce today that we have invited Prime Minister Abe of Japan and President Xi of China for state visits, and we look forward to welcoming other Asian leaders to the White House this year—including President Park of South Korea and President Widodo of Indonesia.

「今日、我々は日本の安倍晋三首相と中国の習国家主席を国賓として招いたことを発表したいと思います。今年は他のアジアの指導者もホワイトハウスに歓迎したく思っています―韓国の朴大統領とインドネシアのウィドド大統領も含めて。」


Abe and Xi
このことは英語ニュースサイト Japan Today の7日のトップニュースだったので知った(AFP通信)。
Obama invites China's Xi, Japan's Abe for state visits
http://www.japantoday.com/category/politics/view/obama-invites-chinas-xi-japans-abe-for-state-visits

英語で探すと、

ジャパンタイムズには共同通信の英語記事
Abe, Xi invited on state visits to U.S. in spring
http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2015/02/07/national/politics-diplomacy/u-s-official-says-abe-xi-invited-to-pay-state-visits-later-this-year/#.VNgFqEc5Cpo

朝日新聞の英語サイトにはロイター通信の記事
U.S. invites Abe, Xi for state visits
http://ajw.asahi.com/article/behind_news/politics/AJ201502070029

毎日新聞も英語サイトに共同の記事
U.S. inviting Abe, Xi for state visits
http://mainichi.jp/english/english/newsselect/news/20150207p2g00m0in108000c.html

読売の英語サイトでも独自記事が。
U.S. invites Abe to visit Washington
http://the-japan-news.com/news/article/0001915671

NHKの国際報道でも英語で報道されている。
US invites Abe, Xi for state visits
http://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/english/news/20150207_09.html

しかし本語の主要メディアの報道がおとなしいような気がする。報道していないわけではないようだが目立たない。安倍首相は2013年2月に訪米したときオバマ大統領からかなりの冷遇をされたこともあり、この「招待」はビッグニュースになってしかるべきと思う。最後に日本の首相が国賓として迎えられたのは2006年の小泉首相のときであるということを考えても。

日本の知り合い数人に連絡しても「知らなかった」と驚いていた。日本語で探したら、TVでは報道があったようだが新聞で大きな扱いをしてはいないようだ。

日経新聞では
米、日中首脳を招待 対「イスラム国」で連携強化
http://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXLASGM07H1A_X00C15A2MM0000/
(紙面にあったかは不明)

産経は非常に簡単な報道。
安倍、習両日中首脳を国賓で招待、米大統領補佐官
http://www.sankei.com/politics/news/150207/plt1502070009-n1.html

また朝日と読売の報道の仕方は明らかにおかしい。

米、首相に年内の公式訪問招請…習主席も国賓で
http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/world/20150207-OYT1T50057.html

米、安倍首相の公式訪問を招請 中韓首脳も年内訪米へ
http://digital.asahi.com/articles/ASH272JLZH27UHBI00B.html?iref=comkiji_txt_end_s_kjid_ASH272JLZH27UHBI00B

両紙とも安倍首相への誘いを中心としており、「習主席も」「中韓首脳も」としているが、ライス氏の発表によると米国は安倍首相と習主席をすでに招待したと、日中をセットとして言っており、それに加えて韓国やインドネシアの首脳も招待する予定だと言っているのだから、安倍首相と習主席への招待を同等に報じるのが当然であろう。曲がった報道とはいえないか。

(11日追記)日本からの情報では、読売新聞はネット版では英語、日本語で報道しているにもかかわらず紙面では報道しなかったようだ。

8日のニューヨーク・タイムズの報道では「国家安全保障会議のパトリック・ベントレル報道官は、ホワイトハウスは習氏と安倍氏による訪問のための双方に都合のいい時期を調整しているところ」と言っている。この表現では同時期の招待を考えているとは言い切れないが、やはり日中の首脳をセットで扱っている。

この記事では習主席の訪米は later this year (「この後、今年中に」)とされている。すぐにでもということではないが、時期は、今年中いつでもあり得るニュアンスだ。安倍氏は4-5月訪米を調整中と以前から報道されているが、どうなるのか。時期が同時期なのか否かは別として、日中首脳の招待をセットで発表したオバマ政権の意向が注目される。

一つ可能性があるのは、戦後70周年の「安倍談話」で侵略戦争への反省や謝罪がトーンダウンされるのではないかという懸念があるが、米国としては安倍氏がこの「談話」によって中国をはじめとする周辺諸国をさらに怒らせるようなことがないように首根っこを押さえておきたいのではないか。

日本側の鈍い反応について考えられることは、安倍首相の訪米を「(中国敵視にもとづく)日米同盟強化のための訪米」と位置付けて日本国内で宣伝したい意向であろうが、安倍氏の訪米が、米国によるアジア諸国首脳の招待の一環と位置付けられ、しかも中国主席の招待と同列に報じられていることが気に入らず、朝日や読売に見られるような曲がった報道や隠ぺいをしているのではないか。そしてそれがこの件についての政府の姿勢を反映している可能性がある。

@PeacePhilosophy


 

Friday, February 06, 2015

Herbert Bix Interview: History denial in Japan started with the Tokyo War Crimes Tribunal not prosecuting Hirohito ハーバート・ビックスインタビュー(朝鮮日報)英語版

Here is the English text of Chosun Ilbo's interview with Herbert Bix, emeritus professor of history and sociology at Binghamton University, and the author of Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan.

『Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan (ヒロヒト天皇と近代日本の形成)』(日本語版は講談社学術文庫『昭和天皇』上・下巻)で知られるハーバート・ビックス氏(ニューヨーク州立大学ビンガムトン校名誉教授)は昨年秋このブログで紹介した。ビクス氏が1月に朝鮮日報のインタビューを受けたときの記事の英語版を提供されたのでここに紹介する。韓国語版のタイトルは「日本の歴史歪曲の始まりは天皇を断罪しなかった東京裁判」、内容は、現在の安倍政権による歴史歪曲の根拠は東京裁判における天皇の戦争責任免罪から始まったという主張、そして東京裁判後、日本人は「天皇に戦争責任がないなら国民にも責任を取る必要がない」という認識を持つようになったと述べている。
朝鮮日報1月15日版
 
[This is an edited version of the interview published in Chosun Ilbo on January 15, 2015] 

What do you think are the problems of history distortion in Japan? Please explain specifically.  

                  Bix: Contemporary Japan’s historiographical problems are wrapped up in disagreements about the Showa Emperor Hirohito’s role during the first two decades of his reign, starting in Dec. 1926 and ending with Imperial Japan’s capitulation on Aug. 15, 1945. The problems extend to Hirohito’s actions in the post-surrender state and were raised recently by the release of the official version of his long life and reign. Showa tenno jitsuroku contains a trove of important documents, but fails to provide a clear picture of Hirohito documents that remain classified. For example, some of the emperor’s exchanges with important foreign leaders are not included. Nor are all materials relating to the emperor’s war leadership held by the Historical Bureau of the Defense Ministry. Furthermore, the Jitsuroku rests on the false premise that the emperor was a non-political, constitutional monarch, whereas Japanese scholarship accumulated over half a century has clearly established just the opposite: Hirohito was, in fact, an activist, dynamic emperor who participated with others in guiding Japan’s wars from 1937 to Japan’s defeat in 1945. Caught up in the fever of war, he was later persuaded to join the war party by selecting General Tojo Hideki as prime minister in late 1941, and thereafter extended the China war throughout the vast Asia-Pacific region. Critical works by independent scholars explain these realities of Japanese decision-making. 

After World War II General Douglas MacArthur, who headed the Allied occupation, protected Hirohito, kept him on the throne, and guaranteed the monarchy’s continued existence by writing it into the Constitution of Japan. At the same time the Constitution contains progressive features owing in part to input by Japanese Marxists and liberals. It strips the emperor of political power, redefines him as the nation’s “symbol,” and outlaws war as an instrument for settling disputes among states. Shortly afterwards, MacArthur immunized Hirohito from the war crimes trials.  It was during the first six months after Japan’s surrender that contemporary problems of history distortion might be said to begin. But if we backtrack even further we can see that the ways in which the modern monarchy was constructed in Japan determined the very nature of the modern Japanese state itself. This formulation puts the spotlight on the complex Meiji system of oligarchic rule. The Meiji Constitution of 1889 defined the emperor as an absolute monarch. Religious myth grounded in state Shinto and in the notion of the emperor as the unifier of rites and governance strengthened his importance. So too did his special relationship with the Japanese military. 

The problems inherent in the Meiji Constitution and other key documents of Imperial Japan came to the fore when ultra-nationalist military officers mounted the stage in the 1930s, calling for a “Showa restoration.” The military leaders, the Court Group, and the Showa emperor all contributed to Japan’s defeat in the war. The other half of the emperor problem was his post-surrender actions and the uses MacArthur made of him. Both contributed to the U.S. failure to complete the occupation reforms, as did the Cold War.  

After the occupation ended the Japanese people rebuilt their economy with U.S. help, while Japanese industries benefitted during the Korean War from the vast Pentagon special procurements system. Concurrently, American elites kept Japan subjugated through treaties and control of oil. Throughout the Cold War and into the post-Cold War Japan’s leaders remained deferential to Washington’s dictates and unwilling to take back their country from American control. 

Germany has deeply reflected about the crimes committed by the Nazi regime. Why do you think Japan didn’t reflect? 

                  Bix: In comparing how Germans and Japanese reflected on war crimes and dealt with issues of accountability, we should first bear in mind that no nation stands on a pedestal in these matters--that includes of course the United States, notorious for its torture and drone murders, but also South Korea under its dictator, Park Chung Hee, who sent more than 312,000 soldiers to fight in Vietnam, where they, along with Americans from all branches of the military, committed widespread atrocities against Vietnamese civilians. 

Second, leaders in occupied, divided Germany knew quite well that by formally repudiating Hitler and his Nazi regime, they strengthened their state and its acceptance by the nations surrounding it. That could not be done so easily in Japan because the occupation (i.e. GHQ) governed indirectly and needed Hirohito, who had legitimized Japan’s wars of aggression, to legitimize MacArthur’s “demilitarization and democratization.” So Hirohito had to be spared from formal investigation that could have led to his indictment and trial. 

Moreover, in assessing the different national responses of Germans and Japanese to war crimes a temporal displacement is involved. Many ordinary Japanese people upon learning the facts reflected on them. Unlike their ruling elites who considered the past a closed book, they confronted war guilt much earlier than the average German citizen who remained anti-Semitic, particularly those who had participated in the invasion of the Soviet Union and the Balkans. Initially Japan went further than Germany in accepting that their soldiers had committed massive crimes in the course of fighting and losing the war.  

For the Japanese people the war crimes trials had a long-term, multi-sided effect on their political attitudes. Real regression on this issue, the open promotion of distorted history, did not occur until after the occupation had ended. The campaign was led from above by conservative ruling elites of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP). In 1957, when Japan was still experiencing its first wave of post-occupation nationalism, Sanko (Burn All, Kill All, Destroy All) appeared. Written by Japanese veterans of the fighting in China, it became a bestselling book, until right wing thugs forced the book’s publisher to discontinue it. Other examples of how the Japanese people were discouraged from learning more about the war crimes their soldiers had once committed followed. In the early 1960s it became more dangerous to criticize or even poke fun at the monarchy, as the publisher of the popular journal Chuo koron, Shimanaka Hoji, discovered on February 1, 1960, when a right wing assassin invaded his residence, murdered his maid, and severely wounded his wife. What ignited the attack was Chuo koron’s publication of a satirical attack on the “symbol monarchy” by the writer Fukazawa Shichiro. Taboos on criticism of the monarchy remained strong and the content of secondary school education continued ignoring the war years until the late 1990s.  

Germany reflection on war crimes only surged ahead of Japan starting in the 1960s. It was younger generations of Germans who were the first to confront the crimes of their parents’ generation. Yet even through the 1990s many Germans clung to the entirely mythical claim of a “clean Wehrmacht” that didn’t participate in mass murders and the destruction of villages, towns, and entire regions behind the front lines. They were unprepared to accept that Hitler’s Wehrmacht had committed crimes of historic proportions. This was demonstrated by the controversy over the first Wehrmacht touring photograph exhibit of the years 1995-99. A few mislabeled photographs caused it to be closed down.  

Japan’s distortion of history has accelerated under Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. Why is he leading the distortion of history? 

Bix: Abe understands that Japan is unique because of its war-renouncing constitution--a document he wants to change. He also understands that issues of war responsibility cannot be pursued in Japan without bumping against Hirohito’s personal leadership during the war, and his rapid transformation afterwards into the nation’s symbol. Abe’s problem is to change Japan into a “normal” state capable of fighting wars in defense of geostrategic interests, which can only be done by changing the nature of Japanese style “democracy.” At the same time he must avoid the Showa emperor issue, which is also a war crimes and impunity issue. All governments in postwar Japan have confronted this problem. But Abe’s hawkish ideological inclinations, not to mention his genealogical background as the grandson of Kishi Nobusuke--wartime munitions minister in the Tojo Hideki cabinet, later imprisoned as an unindicted war crimes suspect--may make him feel the dilemma more acutely than his predecessors did.  

Many of Abe’s political acts, such as his visits to Ise Shrine and Yasukuni Shrine and his membership in the fundamentalist “Shinto Political League” (Shinto seiji renmei) that extols emperor-centered history, indicate his support for Shinto’s growing influence in Japanese politics. He and most of his cabinet belong to the ultra-nationalist “Japan Conference” (Nihon kaigi) which seeks to build grassroots support for the elimination of Article 9 from the Constitution. Abe has implemented policies based on lessons from Japan’s past that have led Japan’s neighbors and many Japanese to conclude correctly that he sympathizes with discredited “traditional” elements and military priorities of the prewar imperial system.

For rightist politicians the issue of “comfort women,” i.e. the sexual enslavement of Korean, Chinese, and Southeast Asian women by wartime Japan’s military, is particularly salient. When Abe succeeded Koizumi Junichiro in September 2006, he revised the liberal 1947 Fundamental Law of Education so as to strengthen state control and cope with the deepening social divisions exacerbated by neo-liberal economic policies. The amended education law allows the teaching of religious education, curtails teachers’ freedom of expression, and could be interpreted as promoting mystical “Japanese-ness.” But Abe also wanted to undo the impression widely held abroad that the imperial armed forces had once forced women into sexual slavery--a charge he feels besmirches Japan’s honor. His one-year in office did not permit him to really address this issue. His return to power five years later in December 2012, allowed him to try again. Now, Abe is fighting an ideological battle to restore the “honor” he thinks Japan lost due to the legal and educational reforms of the occupation and to the San Francisco Peace Treaty that forced Japan to accept all the judgments of the Tokyo War Crimes tribunal. His method has been explicit denial of the historical record of sexual exploitation of women and girls by the Japanese military, which often used civilian brokers to lure women into prostitution. 
 
Abe’s struggle to shape Japanese historical consciousness leads him to clamp down on Japanese mainstream media that use words reminding foreign readers of the Nanjing massacre, a signature event in a war riddled with atrocities. He wants no more reporting either on “comfort women.” The latter issue was first brought to world attention by the former “comfort woman” Kim Hak-sun in 1991. Thereafter other survivors of the Japanese army’s system of sexual slavery stepped forward with their stories. A quarter century ago Uemura Takahashi, a retired Asahi shimbun investigative journalist, told the story of an unnamed Korean “comfort woman,” understood to be Kim. Now, right-wingers accuse Uemura of disseminating “Korean lies.”  They brand him a traitor and threaten him with violence. Not only did the Asahi editors fail to defend Uemura, he also lost his university job at Hokusei Gakuen University in the face of neo-nationalist criticism and threats to his family. Undaunted, Uemura has fought back, launching a libel suit against his defamers: the Bungei Shunju Company and Nishioka Tsutomu, a professor of Korean peninsula studies. It is striking that Abe and Japanese rightists fail to grasp how radically out of step they are with women’s rights movements outside of Japan. 

Abe’s ruling party had a huge victory in the last general election. Do you think the widespread support he received from the Japanese can be interpreted as   history distortion? 

                  Bix: Although the parliamentary elections held on December 14, 2014, yielded a clear victory for Abe’s party, the LDP ran unopposed by a strong candidate and the party actually lost four seats. Abe’s coalition partner, the Komeito, won only 4 new seats. After the vote the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ) remained in disarray but gained new leaders. Japanese voters abandoned the tiny extremist fringe parties. In contrast to the two governing parties, a big winner was the Japan Communist Party (JCP), which stuck to its principles, advocating the return of land confiscated by Americans for military bases and opposing the LDP’s extreme neoliberal economic agenda. Half of Japan’s eligible voters did not even bother to vote. Abe’s victory insures him another four years in power but it needs to be qualified.  

Moreover, although Abe’s historical revisionism is important for him and he uses it to foster nationalism, his primary objective is to insure that Japan remains internationally competitive. It is the economic policies of the second Abe cabinet that produced these recent election results. Abe’s historical revisionism, however, may have contributed indirectly to the unprecedentedly high voter abstention rate and to the turning away from the small fringe parties by swing voters. 

When and where does Japan’s history distortion come from? 

                  Bix: To some extent I think I’ve already answered this question.  

Why was the crime of “comfort women” not addressed at the Tokyo War Crimes Tribunal? 

                  Bix: An authority on this matter is Japanese historian Yoshimi Yoshiaki who wrote a book on the subject.  (See Satoko Oka Norimatsu, “Reexamining the Comfort Women Issue: An Interview with Yoshimi Yoshiaki,” The Asia-Pacific Journal, Vol. 13, Issue 1, No. 1, Jan. 5, 2015). Even though human trafficking was proscribed under international law, crimes against women were not taken seriously at that time. Now in our radically different times they are taken seriously. Abe can improve Japan’s international reputation by changing the way he addresses this problem. 

What can be the solution to deterioration in Korean-Japanese relations and China-Japan relations? Washington is also concerned about the conflicts between these two key U.S. allies. 

Relations between the two Koreas and Japan, and China-Japan are of course fluid, not fixed. The solution of conflicts between these nations can only lie in telling the truth about colonialism and war. In brief, policies that perpetuate U.S. hegemony are central to the interstate conflicts in the Asia-Pacific region. They are the largest part of what must change in order to insure the peaceful resolution of maritime disputes in the East and South China seas. Once the political climate improves and nations turn away from militarism and recognize the UN principle of the mutual equality of states, ongoing problems can be resolved amicably. Because American policy-makers have the dominant hand, it is they who must make the first moves by responding positively to North Korea’s recent overtures and ending the state of war on the peninsula. They need to confront the sorry history of their relations with the two Koreas. It would also help to get at the roots of Korea-Japan and China-Japan disputes if researchers were allowed every opportunity to visit state archives where they could conduct investigations, learn more about the facts, and produce less one-sided narratives of present day conflicts. Good history helps citizens make informed judgments on their governments’ policies. 

More particularly, the peoples of the region support the establishment of a denuclearized Korean peninsula and want America to stress dialogue in relations with North Korea and desist from encouraging militarism and base expansion in Japan and Okinawa--the small island where serious conflict is impending and the problem of U.S. militarism is centered. At present, American and Japanese policy makers are unwilling to listen to the voices of the Okinawan people, though this could change as America’s Asian allies are come to recognize how economically and politically costly it is for them to continue hosting American military bases on their soil. President Barack Obama’s “pivot to Asia,” his attempts to contain China and wage economic warfare against Russia increase the threat of armed conflict. In Seoul, Tokyo, Washington, and Pyongyang changes in policy and tactics as well as attitudes are sorely needed.

Tuesday, February 03, 2015

週間金曜日より―「アンブロークン」は、47日間の漂流と2年の過酷な捕虜生活を生き抜いた男の物語 From Shukan Kinyobi: Film/Book UNBROKEN

『週刊金曜日』1月23日号特集『「反日」と歴史歪曲主義』 より、当ブログ管理者、乗松聡子の記事を紹介します。@PeacePhilosophy




注: 2段目末尾「他の3人と漂流した」⇒正しくは「他の2人と漂流した」です。


(以下、10月26日追記)
ちなみにこの記事に「また、原作の中で日本軍の人肉食に触れている箇所が過度に注目されている。実際日本軍の人肉食は米軍や豪軍などが作成した大量の報告書に詳細に記載されおり、数々の証言も残っている」と書いたのは、この問題に詳しい歴史学者・田中利幸氏の助言を受けてのことでした。田中氏は自身のブログ「吹禅」にこの9月にこのような投稿をしています。

アンジェリーナ・ジョリー監督製作映画と人肉食問題: 戦争の「狂気」と民主主義を考える

週刊金曜日の記事にも書いた通り、この映画『アンブロークン』と日本軍の人肉食は全く関係なく、人肉食の問題にあまり焦点を置くとこの映画の中心テーマである、日本軍による連合軍捕虜の虐待という歴史から目をそらすことにもなりかねないと思います。しかしこの際、人肉食についてもより知識を深めておく機会にもなると思うので、上記の田中氏のブログもぜひ併せて読んでもらいたいと思います。@PeacePhilosophy


★2016年2月6日追記:とうとう日本でも公開のようです!このような広告が新聞に。






Monday, February 02, 2015

A Letter to President Obama: Cancel the Henoko Base Project! オバマ大統領への手紙ー辺野古基地計画を中止してください!

On Februry 2, a group of seventeen writers from US, France, Australia, New Zealand, Canada and Japan sent a letter to President Obama to demand candellation of the new US base construction in Henoko, Okinawa.  2月2日に発送された、ブラウン大学名誉教授スティーブ・ラブソン氏ら17人連名によるオバマ大統領への手紙です。
    
 
Writers for Democracy and Human Rights in Okinawa
1400 Kenmore Avenue, No. B-3
Fredericksburg, VA 22401
 

                                                                                                             February 2, 2015

 

President Barack Obama

The White House

1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20500

 

Dear President Obama: 

We are an international coalition of scholars, journalists, and filmmakers deeply concerned about violations of democracy and human rights in Okinawa. Voters there have expressed overwhelming opposition over many years, in elections, referenda, public opinion polls and demonstrations, to construction of a U.S. Marine air base at Henoko. As a small island prefecture, Okinawa comprises only 0.6% of the nation’s land area and less than 1% of its population yet bears 70% of the total U.S. military presence in Japan. We view this disproportionate burden as a violation of human rights, especially since it affects an ethnic minority that has long suffered discrimination imposed by both the Japanese and U.S. governments.

Imperial Japan forcibly abolished the five-hundred-year-old Ryukyu
Kingdom and annexed it as Okinawa Prefecture in 1879.
For the seven decades that followed, residents paid higher taxes and received fewer social services than those in other prefectures, and Okinawa has remained the nation’s poorest to this day. Okinawans also encounter personal job and housing discrimination in mainland Japan.  Signs in front of employment offices there announced “Okinawans prohibited” before 1945, and could be found in front of apartment buildings as late as the 1970s. Prejudice against people racially and culturally distinct from majority Japanese is perpetuated by a prevalent ideology, repeatedly stated by government officials, that Japan is a “uniquely homogeneous nation.”

Toward the end of the Allied Occupation of Japan (1945-52), the United States agreed to restore Japanese sovereignty to the mainland only on condition that U.S. military occupation of Okinawa continue. For the two decades that followed, Okinawans lived under U.S. military rule which routinely denied them basic legal, property, and political rights. The number of crimes and deadly accidents involving U.S. forces, continuing to this day, soared during the Vietnam War when the American military used Okinawa as a base for training, supply, and B-52 bombings.

The air base at Henoko would have a devastating impact on local residents’ safety, their quality of life, and the environment. Numerous crashes recently of U.S. military aircraft in Okinawa and elsewhere attest to the risks of personal injuries and property damage. The greatly increased noise, especially from helicopters, would disturb the residents. Fuel and smoke pollution would contaminate the air and water. Plans to dump thousands of tons of cement in pristine Oura Bay to build runways would foul the bay, destroying Japan’s sole unblemished coral fields as well as algae vital to the bay’s waters which are the feeding grounds for fish and other animal life, including the dugong, an internationally protected species of sea mammal. Aside from devastating Henoko’s fishing industry, a significant sector of the village’s economy, this would damage the delicate marine ecology, already threatened in many places, on which all life depends. 

The U.S. government has long pressured the Japanese government to move ahead with construction at Henoko, rejecting proposals to locate the base outside Okinawa. This despite the fact that leading members of the Senate Armed Services Committee, including Chairman John McCain and former Chairman Carl Levin, have expressed their strong opposition to building an air base at Henoko. Other committee members called the project “unrealistic, unworkable and unaffordable.” 

Current Governor Onaga Takeshi won his election this month on a platform opposing construction of the base, which was the central issue of the gubernatorial campaign. He received 360,820 votes easily defeating incumbent Nakaima Hirokazu, a belated supporter of the base, who received 261,076 votes. Mayor Inamine Susumu of Nago, in which Henoko is a subdivision, was recently reelected as an opponent of the base’s construction. For the Japanese and U.S. governments to ignore election and referenda results and proceed with construction is a violation of democracy. 

Meanwhile, protest demonstrations, ongoing for more than a decade, have now escalated to major confrontations, including large round-the-clock gatherings outside the gate to Camp Schwab blocking the late-night passage of trucks carrying air base construction materials.  As the enclosed photographs show, a physical encounter resulted last week in which two people were injured by Japanese riot police, a young woman and an eighty-five year-old grandmother. In the bay a convoy of protestors’ canoes confronts Japanese government construction vessels seeking to enter the proposed site. So long as the United States presses forward with construction, these protests are bound to continue with unpredictable human casualties, but certain damage to U.S.-Japan relations at a time of heightened international tensions in the region. 

We urge you respectfully to cancel this project.


Sincerely,

 

Herbert P. Bix
Emeritus Professor, History and Sociology, Binghamton University
 

Shin Chiba
Professor of Political Thought, International Christian University (Tokyo)
 

Alexis Dudden
Professor of History, University of Connecticut
 

Mark Ealey
Translator of Battle of Okinawa-related materials


Norma M. Field
Robert S. Ingersoll Distinguished Service Professor in Japanese Studies in East Asian Languages and Civilizations, University of Chicago


Laura Hein
Professor, Department of History, Northwestern University


Paul Jobin
Associate Professor, Department of East Asian Studies, Paris Diderot University

 
John Junkerman, Film director and Professor, Waseda University (Tokyo)
 

Peter J. Kuznick
Professor of History and Director, Nuclear Studies Institute, American University, Washington, DC

 
Gavan McCormack
Emeritus Professor, Australian National University

 
Katherine Muzik
Research Associate in Marine Biology, National Tropical Botanical Garden, Lawai Bay, Kauai, Hawaii
 

Koichi Nakano
Professor of Comparative Politics, Sophia University (Tokyo)

 
Osamu Nishitani
Professor of Philosophy, Rikkyo University (Tokyo)
 

Satoko Oka Norimatsu
Director, Peace Philosophy Centre, Vancouver, B.C., Canada
 

Steve Rabson
Professor Emeritus of East Asian Studies, Brown University
Veteran, United States Army, Henoko, Okinawa

 
Lawrence Repeta
Professor, Meiji University (Tokyo)

 
Mark Selden
Senior Research Associate, East Asia Program, Cornell University and Coordinator, The Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus

**********************************************************************************

(Signed after February 2)

Yu-cheng Wang, Associate Professor, Department of Law, National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan

翁長知事への手紙―埋め立て承認撤回の宣言を!

沖縄在住の宮島玲子さんからの翁長知事への手紙を紹介します。

知事への手紙はここで受け付けています。
http://www.pref.okinawa.lg.jp/site/chijiko/kohokoryu/kense/chiji/tayori.html

【翁長知事へのお手紙】
前略ごめん下さいませ。

 日々、沖縄県知事として、140万県民のためにご尽力下さり誠に有難うございます。
...
さて、本日お手紙を認めましたのは、他でもありません。

 辺野古新基地建設阻止に向けた知事のお考えについて詳しくお伺いしたくペンを取った次第です。

ご存知のように辺野古シュワブゲート前での県警、そして大浦湾での海保の行動は、もはや犯罪的と言っても過言ではありません。

 非暴力に徹している市民に対し有無を言わせぬ圧倒的な力で威圧し、危険極まりない暴力の行使により怪我まで負わせている状況が継続されています。

県警を率いるのは翁長知事だと伺いましたが、幾度要請しても聞き入れられないのであれば、県警本部長を更迭、或いは予算の凍結といった対応もお考えになっているでしょうか。

ありとあらゆる方策を練り、様々な手段を講じなければ、取り返しのつかないことになります。

そして、何よりもシュワブゲート前では24時間体制の座り込みが続いている中、市民の疲労もピークに達していることを知事はご存知でしょうか。

 皆さん、日中の仕事を終え夜中にパトロールをし、寝ずに又仕事に戻られるのです。

 一度ご体験されればお分かりになるかと思いますが、この寒風吹き荒ぶ時期、テントの中では一睡も出来ません。

 又いつ資材搬入のための大型トラックが入るのかという緊張感で心身ともに疲弊し、まさに疲労困憊の日々が続いています。

家族との団欒をも犠牲にし、自分達の命を削り、辺野古の海を守ろうとしている市民を一日も早く普通の生活に戻してあげたい、温かい布団でゆっくりと休める、そのような日々を送れるようにしてあげたい、そう願わない県民はいないはずです。

知事も勿論、県民と同じくそのように切望されていることとお察し致します。

そして、それが出来るのはご存知のように、知事自らの埋め立て承認取り消し・撤回以外にはありません。

日本政府の暴挙は許し難い、言語道断な行為です。

 工事中止の要請をしても全く歯牙にもかけぬ民主主義国家として恥ずべき行為です。

 前知事の埋め立て承認を印籠のように示しながら、まさに牙を向いて私達県民に襲いかかって来るこの状況下、もはや一刻の猶予もありません。

まずは知事自らが、埋め立て承認の撤回宣言をし、同時に書面で日米両政府にその宣言文を速やかに送って下さい。

埋め立てに瑕疵があるか否かの判断を待っていれば、辺野古の海は取り返しのつかないことになり、海上で、そしてシュワブゲート前で日夜尽力している市民達の犠牲は筆舌に尽くし難いものとなるでしょう。

まずは声高らかに承認の撤回を、その後取り消しに向けて委員会の方々と協議し策を練れば良いのではありませんか。

一分一秒も、もはやこの段階では無駄には出来ないことを、知事が一番ご存知かと思います。

 県民の民意で今回知事になったのだと仰っている頼もしいお言葉と共に、ぜひ一日も早い承認・撤回宣言をして頂きたいと願うばかりです。

知事からの頼もしいお返事をお待ちしております。

時節柄くれぐれもご自愛下さいませ。

かしこ

****************

上記の他に、下記の文章も付け加えておきました。
↓
知事へのお便りには必ずお返事が頂けるということですので、再度質問を要約します。

① 県警本部長の更迭、あるいは予算の凍結を考えておられるのか。
考えていないのであれば、その理由は何か。

② 海上工事を止めることが喫緊の知事の仕事だと思うが、埋め立て承認撤回宣言をするつもりは、おありなのか。

もし、ないとすれば、どのように現場の工事を速やかに止めることが出来るのか。その策を教えて頂きたい。

お手数をおかけ致しますがご回答のほど、どうか宜しくお願い申し上げます。

Sunday, February 01, 2015

Henoko/Oura Bay is already being destroyed with concrete blocks weighing 20 - 45 tons! 大浦湾に20-45トンのコンクリートブロックが投げ込まれてすでに環境が破壊されている!

日本語では、目取真俊氏のブログを参照。

Yoshio Shimoji, a writer based in Naha, Okinawa, on January 31 alerted the international media on what is going on in Henoko, Okinawa, citing author Shun MEDORUMA's blog. Henoko is where Japanese and US government are forcing the construction of a new US military airbase and port that requires massive reclamation of the pristine ocean, despite the legal, environmental concerns over the plan and 80% of Okinawan population opposing to it.

Shimoji says:

"Below are some photographs of the venues of Henoko construction site run on Shun Medoruma’s blog.  Concrete blocks being dumped onto the Henoko seabed are not one-ton blocks as I assumed.  Their weights seem to range from 20 tons to 45 tons as Medoruma writes.

The destruction of mother nature at Henoko has thus begun despite Okinawa’s and the world’s vociferous opposition!"





"The following diagram from the Feb. 1 Ryukyu Shinpo shows how the construction work will proceed. Huge caissons cast at a plant in Mie Prefecture will be carried by barges as far as Henoko where they are sunk onto the seabed, filled with sands/rocks and then sealed with concrete. After that, dirt for landfill is dumped into an area surrounded by the caissons."

 
 
Shun Medoruma, who frequently participats in the Henoko protest, says on his January 31 blog:
 
"Since two large barges with cranes appeared on Oura Bay on January 27, concrete blocks have been thrown into the ocean. I cannot imagine how many corals and seagrass beds have already been destroyed. The Japanese government/Ministry of Defense/Okinawa Defense Bureau have been hiding their destruction of the Oura Bay's environment by making a large area off-limit (2 kilometers off the coast of Camp Schwab) and placing oil fences around it. "
 
"Reclamation work has not been started yet, but installation of these huge concrete blocks on the seabed are already damaging the rich biodiversity of Oura Bay. The Environmental Impact Assessment done by the Okinawa Defense Bureau (Okinawa Branch of Japanese Ministry of Defense) is nothing but one that deceives Okinawan residents. What would the seabed look like, with concrete blocks as heavy as 45 tons being thrown onto it? The reason why ODB excludes media reporters from the restricted water area is because they do not want the public to know the reality of the environmental destruction in the area."
 

Also see:
 

A Letter to Okinawa's Governor Takeshi Onaga from Fifteen International Scholars and Researchers
 

Gavan McCormack, Storm Ahead: Okinawa’s Outlook for 2015
 
Douglas Lummis, The Bus to Henoko: Riot Police and Okinawan Citizens Face-off over New Marine Base http://www.japanfocus.org/events/view/240
 

Hideki Yoshikawa, An Appeal from Okinawa to the US Congress.Futenma Marine Base Relocation and its Environmental Impact: U.S. Responsibility